12 Days of Cookbooks (!!!) — Chatting About The Season’s New Books with Margaret Roach
This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
AA
♬♬♬ It’s the most wonderful time of the year… ♬♬♬
I hum this to myself a lot: When my first CSA arrives in June. When the first good tomatoes all but fall of the vine in early September. When snowflakes the size of golf balls drop from the sky. AND, most of all, when it’s time to talk about cookbooks with my friend Margaret Roach, the master gardener behind A Way to Garden
Last year, we talked about all-time favorites, the first books we ever owned, and the ones with the most besmirched pages. This year, we’ve kept our chat to the latest crop: the fall and winter 2018 cookbooks, and we hope our chat might give you some ideas for gift giving this season. Rest assured, there is something for everyone — the bakers, the boozers, the pie lovers, the pizza lovers, the Ina fans, the Dorie fans, the gadget collectors, and more.
Read the transcript or listen here.
I have not had a chance to cook from all of the books we discussed, and there are many others I haven’t even had a chance to page through yet, namely Emily: The Cookbook, which is #1 on my Christmas wishlist—Santa, hope you’re reading. That said, I have cooked from a number of the season’s new books, and I’ve included some notes below.

ALSO, Margaret and I are each giving away 12 cookbooks (!!!). To enter, leave a comment below: tell me what your favorite cookbook is for gifting (or just your favorite) and a little bit about why. Now, go double your chances to win by copying your comment into the comment box over at Margaret’s website.
Starting Monday Dec. 3, 2018, we’ll each draw one random winner a day through Dec. 14th. Here’s the order of the 12 Days of giveaways. The list will be updated daily to reflect the winner.
- Season: UPDATE: Winner is Cara Priddy
- Everyday Dorie UPDATE: Winner is Frank Wilk
- Israeli Soul: UPDATE: Winner is KARA P.
- Cooking with Scraps: UPDATE: Winner is Katherine Hubbard
- Sister Pie: UPDATE: Winner is Renee D
- Cook Like a Pro: UPDATE: Winner is Jo Kurdzeil
- Genius Desserts: UPDATE: Winner is Susan Rode
- Skinny Taste One and Done: UPDATE: Winner is Amy Olmsted
- All About Cake: UPDATE: Winner is Marie Guiles
- Milk Street Tuesday Nights: UPDATE: Winner is Sarah Bach
- Comfort in an Instant: UPDATE: WINNER is Michelle Swift
- Now and Again: UPDATE: WINNER is Paulina Muratore
One entry per person. Entries end at midnight Thursday, Dec. 13, before the final drawing. U.S. only. Good luck to all.

Category #1: Weeknight-ish/Everyday Cooking







Cook90: On January 1st 2016, David Tamarkin of Epicurious resolved to cook more — to cook 3 meals a day for an entire month — an experiment he called “Cook90”. In the end, he emerged a better, faster, and healthier cook, and he has since inspired hundreds of thousands of others to take the challenge. His cookbook, Cook90, outlines exactly how to do it: recipes, strategies, meal plans, and more.

Category #2: Global Flavors





Category #3: Baking






Category #4: Nose-to-Tail

Waste Not: Learned about this one through Margaret and her podcast with Top Chef star Tiffany Derry. Waste Not is a new cookbook from the James Beard Foundation and a campaign of anti-food waste advocacy spearheaded by that organization.
Now and Again: The latest from Julia Turshen, who believes a complete meal doesn’t have to be difficult or expensive, that leftovers can lead to inventive/fun cooking, and that gathering people around the table for a meal is a good thing. Organize both by season and menu — a brunch or an easy Thanksgiving. Helpful tips about what can be made ahead of time. Each menu is followed by a section called “It’s Me Again,” which offers a few recipes for using the leftovers.
And last but not least:
Rebekah Peppler’s Apéritif: For Francophiles and beyond, Apèritif offers recipes for both classic and modern French cocktails, along with French-inspired bites and hors d’oeuvres.

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
740 Comments on “12 Days of Cookbooks (!!!) — Chatting About The Season’s New Books with Margaret Roach”
My favorite cookbook of all time is either Plenty or Plenty More, but I love gifting both of the Smitten Kitchen cookbooks 🙂
Alison Roman’s Dining In is a current favorite, I’ll be giving out a couple of copies as gifts! I’ve been cooking from it all year, I’ve actually made all but one recipe from it, and I’ve made a ton more than once because the flavors are just so special. One copy is going to my father in law who can’t stop talking about the paprika rubbed chicken I made for thanksgiving.
My favorite as a reference book is the Joy of Cooking, got that 34 years ago. You guessed it as a shower gift before my wedding. Both book and marriage hold true. My favorite recent purchase is Sourdough by Sarah Owens. Started a sourdough a couple of years ago. This book has very creative recipes with wonderful off the beaten path flavors and gorgeous photos
How can you pick a favorite! Currently I’m loving Giada’s Feel Good food. With the holidays I love having simple and not overly rich or filling recipes.
Sister Pie is such an amazing cookbook to gift! I have it and it’s full of unique, well thought out recipes and her support of local Detroit businesses cannot be beat.
Love Ina Garten’s cook books. Ina’s recipes are flawless and always delicious.
I own all and love all of Ina Gartens Cookbooks and cook from them constantly.
However, the one cookbook I have gifted the most is by Carla Snyder, 300 Soups.
I highly respect Carla. I took a professional series of cooking classes and she was my instructor at Western Reserve School of Cooking in Hudson Ohio. All of her cookbooks are delicious, but I am a huge fan of soups. It’s a meal in a bowl. It makes several meals that are easy to reheat. They usually have my ideal combination and ratios of protein, vegetables, carbs and fat. They warm my heart as well as tummy, and are as versatile as any food with a zillion combinations of those proteins + Vegetables + starch + fat.
Carla is amazing in this cookbook and the variety of soups in here is delicious and amazing.
Give me my my Crueset braiser, a good knife and Carla’s cookbook, and I am one happy home chef.
And who doesn’t love soups???
I love cookbooks and am always trying to keep up with the newest ones — am loving your list b/c it a) confirms some recent purchases that I’ve not yet had time to get into and b) cuts through a long list I was thinking through for my Christmas list. Thanks! My pattern with cookbooks is that I end up finding only 3-4 recipes/cookbook that stick with me for the long haul. So, my favorites tend to be those with a higher ratio of recipe harvesting, a few include classics like Julia Child’s Julia’s Kitchen Wisdom and Mark Bittmans’ How to Cook Everything, and a newer fav is Andrea Bemis’ Dishing Up The Dirt.
The cookbook I give as a gift is Mark Bittman’s “How To Cook Everything -the basics”. It is a great starter cookbook that teaches what other cookbooks take for granted. It is not a children’s book, it’s really for people who just never learned to cook. I am usually giving it to young people setting up their own household. However, I am an experienced cook and still learned from it. He has an easy way of explaining things and the visuals are great. This book is more than just recipes, he teaches techniques…a real ‘how to’. Some experienced cookbook writers lose sight of when they use terms that others don’t understand. This is a really good basic cookbook that teaches you how to cook!
My favorite cookbook to gift is either Jerusalem by Ottolenghi or the Icelandic cookbook Í boði náttúrunnar – it has beautiful photos and gives plenty of ideas about how to use seasonal Icelandic ingrediets.
Love your blog ❤️
My absolute favorite is a local church cookbook. It’s full of simple hearty recipes, including a banana nut bread recipe that I’ve made a million times.
Any INA book… they are always failproof!
I love Salt Fat Acid Heat by Samin Nosrat. It helps that there’s now a Netflix documentary that allows you to see it in action. It’s such a valuable reference and has helped me become a better cook.
Currently, I’m liking Cravings and Magnolia Kitchen. But I always need more cookbooks because you never know where your next “favorite” will come from!
Moosewood Cookbook!
No matter the season, I’m constantly grabbing Vegetarian Cooking for Everyone, by Deborah Madison. I can always find something new!
I love Ottolenghi’s Plenty for gift giving when I know the person is someone who loves to veer off and cook his more ethnic dishes! It’s wonderful. For a bridal shower I often give Mark Bittman’s How to Cook Everything. Such a good solid resource for a new family!
Only because the rules say it should be so, I’ll choose one (of course i would add all of them to my library). I own Israeli soul and would therefore gift it. The recipes are simple enough to make at home yet bring the same comfort and excitement as if buying from a street vendor in Israel. Israeli soul is such an appropriate title for these recipes.
A part of me wants to keep my favorite a secret because it is out of print (good thing I have a few extras for gifting- because I love giving it away.) it is called The 150 Best American Recipes. It’s from a series that used to come out every year, wherein the authors would compile their favorite recipes from that year- whether they came from a cookbook, a magazine, or an email chain. This book is a collection of their favorite recipes from all the previous years. It’s wonderful and varied. I can’t pick a favorite recipe- the pancake and the cinnamon roll recipes ended my quest for the perfect ones. The black bean burger has won many guests over and only takes 5 minutes to make. Do not get me started on the butternut squash soup.
I love all of Ina Garten’s cookbooks and have 7, but my favorite is The Barefoot Contessa Cookbook.
I peruse them all, but find my go to above.
Sooooo many cookbooks, so little time to cook. What’s a gal to do when she’s a nurse working 40 hours a week, and bone tired when she gets home, but would soooooooo much rather cook? I really rely on America’s Test Kitchen recipes – they NEVER fail and are ALWAYS good. Thank you for this essay on all the new cookbooks out there. Hoping to find the time to read them all.
I love any local cookbook. It is like a photo of the area’s culture!
Pie book, cookie book… anything else needed to be said???? Then there’s the simple book too????
I love all cookbooks by Ina Garten. Her recipes always work out perfectly and are so delicious. I have all her books except Cook Like a Pro. So far, my favorite is Back to Basics. Would love to win any of these cookbooks on the contest!
Loving the reviews and what a great giveaway! I grew up with local church and PTA books of local recipes and The Joy of Cooking. I cannot pick an all time favorite but I’ve been a long time fan of Ina Garten, Dorie Greenspan and Christopher Kimball. I do not own many cookbooks and would be honered if Santa payed me a visit and I won any of these books!
I love any of Domenica Marchetti’s books for gifting-especially The Glorious Pasta of Italy and also The Glorious Vegetables of Italy. Her recipes are well written, easy to follow and great interpretations of Italian recipes.
A favorite of mine recently is the Sprouted Kitchen cookbook – everything is easy to prepare and so delicious! It’s the book I reach for most often when I need some inspiration (that I don’t get on Instagram…). Thanks for hosting a giveaway!
Love gifting Dinner In An Instant by Melissa Clark to anyone with a new InstaPot. It helps demystify the machine and the recipes are delicious.
I love all cookbooks, but Ina Garten’s are always easy, dependable and fabulous! For old times sake, though, I sometimes reach into the past and grab a gem from The Silver Palate.
My most recent favorite is Love Real Food by Kathryne Taylor (Cookie & Kate). He vegetarian recipes are so approachable and so reliably delicious, and I really love her ethos on food in general!